The Caddicarus Show

The Caddicarus Show is Jim Caddick's main show, in which he reviews games with a more exaggerated and comedic tone than his modern Wednesday reviews. From Seasons 1-10 he would decide whether a game deserves to be "slaughtered" or "salvaged", but as of Season 11 that, along with the old catchphrases, has stopped. On August 1, 2018, Caddy announced that the format of the show would change after Season 10 and The Caddicarus Show would be moved to Saturday - after having consistently been a Sunday series since Season 2.

''Note: As of 2019, many of the pre-Season 11 episodes have been renamed to either simply the name of the game reviewed or to omit explict language. This list uses the original names of the episodes with the actual game's title included underneath.''